My name is Omar Alam Rana. I am a Muslim and an Oklahoman. I have a few questions for you about your proposed interim study about Radical Islam and statements you have made on the matter.
You have made many comments on Islam. Once even going as far as to state there being “[no] difference between moderate and radical Islam”. Do you believe that all Muslims are radical? If so, I think it would be highly improbable that all 1.6 billion Muslims in the world adhere to radical principals.
I’ll use myself as an example. I was born in Tulsa, not too far from your district. At Riverfield High School I was on Student Council and I won a state championship in Speech and Debate. While attending The University of Kansas during my undergrad, I was in many leadership positions in organizations including president of my fraternity, an Executive staff member of Student Government and a committee leader on the Student Activities Board. When I graduated I won a University Award awarded to only 10 graduating seniors. I am now enrolled in law school for the fall. Do you think I am a radical? I pay my taxes on time and I vote regularly. By most accounts, I think many people would consider me a model citizen. Does my name and religion cancel all of that out?
In the bill you cited San Bernardino and Moore as reasons why Radical Islam is a threat in the United States. These events were tragic, and I mourned these events like every other American. However, after thorough investigations it was concluded that Islamic Extremist groups were not directly involved in either of these events. It would seem that your logic is that because people who claim to be Muslim perpetrated them, they automatically representative of all Muslims. Using that logic, can I hold all Christian or White Americans accountable for the actions of the extremists who perpetrated Newtown, Aurora, or Charleston shootings?
You state at the end of your bill that the purpose of the study will be to have “experts” create a study that will then lead to solutions that are solicited by the public and will result in legislation. If you are having “experts” develop a study then what is the point of soliciting solutions from the general public who are not “experts” in this area? I am skeptical about what “experts” you will choose to conduct the study and, I am even more even more skeptical about having solutions referring to an identity I hold be solicited to the general Oklahoma public?
I wonder, why is this so important to you? Is this really the most important use of your time as a public servant? In 2011 and 2012 taxpayers paid more than $300,000 on an unconstitutional state question and subsequent federal lawsuit. A lawsuit which resulted in said law being struck down as unconstitutional by the 10th US Circuit Court. Is the chip on your shoulder towards Islam really worth your constituent’s time and money? Tom Stites, your Democratic challenger, has said that he would rather use the time proposed for this bill to find solutions to fixing the budget crisis or funding education. Quite frankly I agree, even though I am not directly your constituent. After studying your politics ad this proposed interim study, I feel personally victimized by the simple fear mongering political tactics. Politics which are concerned with disenfranchising me. So, Representative John Bennett, my last question is simply; why do you hate me?
Share:
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn
The Muslim Post
O mankind! We created you from a single (pair) of a male and a female, and made you into nations and tribes, that ye may know each other (not that ye may despise (each other). Verily the most honoured of you in the sight of God is (he who is) the most righteous of you. And God has full knowledge and is well acquainted (with all things). ~ Quran 49:13
Reports indicated that the Israeli defense forces had prior knowledge of Hamas’s intentions to execute an assault on Israeli territory more than a year before
As the crescent moon heralds the arrival of Ramadan, a wave of tranquility and spiritual anticipation envelops the Muslim community worldwide. This sacred month offers
American Muslim responds to Representative John Bennett
Dear Representative John Bennett,
My name is Omar Alam Rana. I am a Muslim and an Oklahoman. I have a few questions for you about your proposed interim study about Radical Islam and statements you have made on the matter.
You have made many comments on Islam. Once even going as far as to state there being “[no] difference between moderate and radical Islam”. Do you believe that all Muslims are radical? If so, I think it would be highly improbable that all 1.6 billion Muslims in the world adhere to radical principals.
I’ll use myself as an example. I was born in Tulsa, not too far from your district. At Riverfield High School I was on Student Council and I won a state championship in Speech and Debate. While attending The University of Kansas during my undergrad, I was in many leadership positions in organizations including president of my fraternity, an Executive staff member of Student Government and a committee leader on the Student Activities Board. When I graduated I won a University Award awarded to only 10 graduating seniors. I am now enrolled in law school for the fall. Do you think I am a radical? I pay my taxes on time and I vote regularly. By most accounts, I think many people would consider me a model citizen. Does my name and religion cancel all of that out?
In the bill you cited San Bernardino and Moore as reasons why Radical Islam is a threat in the United States. These events were tragic, and I mourned these events like every other American. However, after thorough investigations it was concluded that Islamic Extremist groups were not directly involved in either of these events. It would seem that your logic is that because people who claim to be Muslim perpetrated them, they automatically representative of all Muslims. Using that logic, can I hold all Christian or White Americans accountable for the actions of the extremists who perpetrated Newtown, Aurora, or Charleston shootings?
You state at the end of your bill that the purpose of the study will be to have “experts” create a study that will then lead to solutions that are solicited by the public and will result in legislation. If you are having “experts” develop a study then what is the point of soliciting solutions from the general public who are not “experts” in this area? I am skeptical about what “experts” you will choose to conduct the study and, I am even more even more skeptical about having solutions referring to an identity I hold be solicited to the general Oklahoma public?
I wonder, why is this so important to you? Is this really the most important use of your time as a public servant? In 2011 and 2012 taxpayers paid more than $300,000 on an unconstitutional state question and subsequent federal lawsuit. A lawsuit which resulted in said law being struck down as unconstitutional by the 10th US Circuit Court. Is the chip on your shoulder towards Islam really worth your constituent’s time and money? Tom Stites, your Democratic challenger, has said that he would rather use the time proposed for this bill to find solutions to fixing the budget crisis or funding education. Quite frankly I agree, even though I am not directly your constituent. After studying your politics ad this proposed interim study, I feel personally victimized by the simple fear mongering political tactics. Politics which are concerned with disenfranchising me. So, Representative John Bennett, my last question is simply; why do you hate me?
Share:
The Muslim Post
Social Media
Most Popular
Tragic Stabbings in Sydney Leave Six Dead, Community in Mourning
Challenging Bias: How Assal Rad Seeks to Reframe Western Media’s Coverage of Gaza
The Media Reports on October 7th Surprised Attack by Hamas
Welcoming Ramadan: Embracing the Blessings of the Holy Month
Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter
Tags
Related Posts
Tragic Stabbings in Sydney Leave Six Dead, Community in Mourning
In a horrifying incident that has left the Sydney community in shock, six people were tragically killed in a stabbing attack at a bustling shopping
Challenging Bias: How Assal Rad Seeks to Reframe Western Media’s Coverage of Gaza
Assal Rad, a scholar with a Ph.D. in Modern Middle Eastern history, has been actively challenging the way Western media reports on Israeli actions in
The Media Reports on October 7th Surprised Attack by Hamas
Reports indicated that the Israeli defense forces had prior knowledge of Hamas’s intentions to execute an assault on Israeli territory more than a year before
Welcoming Ramadan: Embracing the Blessings of the Holy Month
As the crescent moon heralds the arrival of Ramadan, a wave of tranquility and spiritual anticipation envelops the Muslim community worldwide. This sacred month offers